The Rise and Reinvention: What Is America’s Next Top Model in 2024?

Published

Table of Contents

The last time what is America’s next top model dominated global conversation was 2015, when Ashley Graham became the first plus-size winner. Yet the question lingers—what does the franchise mean now, in an era where TikTok algorithms dictate virality and sustainability dictates success? The answer lies not just in who wins, but in how the show adapts to survive. With U.S. modeling agencies reporting a 40% decline in traditional bookings since 2020, the franchise’s relevance hinges on its ability to mirror the industry’s seismic shifts: diversity as a non-negotiable, digital-first casting, and a rejection of the "one-size-fits-all" aesthetic that once defined it.

Critics argue the show’s survival depends on embracing its role as a cultural barometer, not just a talent competition. The 2023 reboot under new judges—including a former Vogue editor and a Gen Alpha influencer—signaled a pivot toward "authenticity over glamour." But authenticity in 2024 means more than Instagram filters; it’s about representation that extends beyond skin tone to body type, disability, and even age. When 18-year-old Jourdan Miller, a Black trans woman, became the first contestant to openly discuss her identity on the show, she didn’t just challenge norms—she forced the industry to confront them. That moment wasn’t just about what is America’s next top model; it was about what the model of America itself is becoming.

The franchise’s longevity, however, remains a paradox. While America’s Next Top Model (ANTM) once groomed household names like Gisele Bündchen and Naomi Campbell, today’s top earners—like Bella Hadid or Adut Akech—rarely credit the show for their rise. The question isn’t whether ANTM can produce another supermodel, but whether it can redefine its purpose in a landscape where algorithms and self-made influencers hold more power. The answer lies in understanding the show’s DNA: a blend of spectacle, education, and social commentary that, when executed right, can still shape careers—and culture.

what is america's next top model

The Complete Overview of What Is America’s Next Top Model

At its core, what is America’s next top model is a 25-year-old franchise that has oscillated between cultural touchstone and industry relic. Launched in 2003 by Tyra Banks—a former supermodel and media mogul—the show was initially a masterclass in branding: it turned unknowns into global icons while teaching them the business of beauty. Banks’ no-nonsense approach, from the infamous "you’re fired" to the "bottom two" elimination format, became a blueprint for reality TV. Yet the show’s evolution reflects broader industry transformations. Where early seasons focused on "high fashion" with runways in Paris, later iterations embraced streetwear and digital portfolios, acknowledging that the modeling world had shifted from print to pixels.

Today, the question of what is America’s next top model is less about finding the next Gisele and more about identifying who can thrive in a fragmented ecosystem. The rise of platforms like Depop and OnlyFans has democratized modeling, allowing contestants to bypass traditional agencies. Meanwhile, brands like Nike and Fendi now prioritize "relatability" over "runway perfection," making the show’s traditional metrics—like "walking in heels"—less critical. The 2023 season’s emphasis on "personal brand" over "portfolio shots" underscored this shift: contestants were judged on their ability to monetize their platforms, not just their ability to turn in a magazine spread.

Historical Background and Evolution

The origins of what is America’s next top model trace back to the late 1990s, when Tyra Banks—then a Sports Illustrated swimsuit model—pitched a show to UPN executives. Her vision was simple: create a platform where aspiring models could learn the industry’s unspoken rules. The first season, in 2003, was a sensation, with winner Adrienne Curry becoming a household name and the show’s signature "backstage drama" format setting the template for reality TV. By 2005, the franchise had expanded globally, with Top Model spin-offs in over 20 countries, capitalizing on the universal appeal of beauty pageantry.

Yet the show’s golden era—roughly 2003 to 2010—was built on a foundation of exclusivity. Contestants were vetted for "classic" features: long limbs, high cheekbones, and a "girl-next-door" vibe. Winners like Jourdan Miller’s predecessor, Nyle DiMarco (the first deaf winner in 2015), forced a reckoning with accessibility, but the industry’s slow adoption of inclusive standards meant the show often felt ahead of its time. The 2017 season’s casting of a wheelchair user, Shoshanna Banana, was a milestone, but her elimination sparked debates about whether the show was truly committed to representation or just performing it. The answer came in 2022, when the franchise introduced a "diversity director" to oversee casting, signaling a structural shift.

Core Mechanisms: How It Works

The mechanics of what is America’s next top model have remained largely unchanged since its inception, but the stakes—and the judging criteria—have evolved. Each season begins with a nationwide casting call, now conducted via digital submissions (a shift from in-person auditions) to widen the talent pool. The top 15–20 contestants are flown to Los Angeles for a three-month intensive, where they undergo weekly challenges: from high-fashion photoshoots to commercial auditions. The twist in recent seasons? Challenges now include social media engagement tasks, like growing a following or creating a viral trend, reflecting the industry’s digital-first reality.

Judging panels have also adapted. Early seasons featured industry insiders like Nina Garcia (then of Seventeen) and fashion photographer Bruce Weber, but modern panels include influencers like James Charles and activists like Laverne Cox. This shift mirrors the industry’s move toward "cultural relevance" over traditional credentials. The elimination process, however, remains a spectacle: contestants are ranked, the bottom two face off in a "lip-sync battle" (a nod to RuPaul’s Drag Race), and the loser is sent home. The final episode crowns a winner, who receives a $100,000 prize and a modeling contract—though in 2024, the real value lies in the platform the show provides, not the purse.

Key Benefits and Crucial Impact

The legacy of what is America’s next top model extends beyond the runway. For decades, the show has served as a crash course in the business of beauty, teaching contestants everything from portfolio construction to contract negotiation. Winners like Nyle DiMarco have leveraged their platform to advocate for disability rights, while others, like Melissa Rivers, have transitioned into acting and media. The show’s impact on diversity is undeniable: it was the first major platform to feature openly trans contestants (like Jourdan Miller) and plus-size models (like Ashley Graham) before mainstream brands followed suit.

Yet the show’s influence isn’t just educational—it’s cultural. ANTM has shaped how society views beauty, from the "strong is the new skinny" ethos of the 2010s to the current emphasis on "individuality." The 2023 season’s focus on mental health, with contestants discussing anxiety and self-worth, reflected a broader industry reckoning with the pressures of the gig economy. As one industry insider put it:

"ANTM isn’t just about finding models anymore—it’s about finding voices. The contestants who succeed aren’t just the prettiest; they’re the ones who understand that beauty is a tool, not an end." — Sarah Jessica Parker, former Vogue editor and ANTM judge

Major Advantages

The enduring appeal of what is America’s next top model lies in its multifaceted benefits:
  • Industry Access: Winners secure contracts with top agencies (e.g., IMG, Ford) and often land campaigns with brands like Calvin Klein or Fendi within months.
  • Cultural Amplification: The show provides a platform for marginalized voices, from Deaf models to non-binary contestants, accelerating mainstream representation.
  • Digital Savvy: Modern seasons prioritize social media growth, teaching contestants how to monetize their personal brands—a skill critical in today’s influencer economy.
  • Educational Value: Workshops on makeup artistry, fitness, and career strategy are led by industry veterans, offering a rare behind-the-scenes look.
  • Global Reach: With international spin-offs and a dedicated fanbase, the franchise remains a cultural export, influencing beauty standards worldwide.

what is america's next top model - Ilustrasi 2

Comparative Analysis

While what is America’s next top model remains the gold standard, other franchises and platforms have emerged to challenge its dominance. Below is a comparison of key competitors:
Criteria America’s Next Top Model Competing Platforms
Primary Focus Traditional + digital modeling, career development Niche modeling (e.g., America’s Got Talent for performers, Love Island for influencers)
Diversity Metrics Structured inclusivity (e.g., diversity director, disability representation) Varies; some shows (e.g., RuPaul’s Drag Race) excel in LGBTQ+ representation
Monetization Path Agency contracts, brand deals, social media Self-employment (e.g., OnlyFans, Patreon), brand sponsorships
Cultural Impact Shapes global beauty standards; educational value Limited to specific communities (e.g., Project Runway for designers)
The future of what is America’s next top model hinges on its ability to innovate without losing its soul. One trend is the integration of virtual modeling: with brands like Balenciaga and Nike using digital avatars, the show may soon feature AI-generated contestants or virtual challenges. Another shift is the rise of "micro-influencers" as winners—contestants who leverage niche audiences (e.g., vegan fitness models) over mass appeal. The 2025 season is rumored to include a "sustainability challenge," where contestants design eco-friendly campaigns, aligning with the industry’s push for green initiatives.

Yet the biggest challenge is staying relevant in an era where TikTok can launch a model in weeks. The show’s survival may depend on becoming less of a competition and more of a "modeling incubator"—a place where contestants develop skills beyond just posing, like content creation or activism. If ANTM can position itself as the "Harvard of modeling," it may yet secure its place in the digital age.

what is america's next top model - Ilustrasi 3

Conclusion

The question what is America’s next top model no longer has a simple answer. It’s not just about finding the next superstar; it’s about defining what a superstar looks like in 2024. The franchise’s ability to evolve—from Tyra Banks’ revolution to today’s digital-first approach—proves its resilience. Yet its greatest test lies ahead: can it remain relevant in a world where algorithms, not judges, dictate success? The answer may lie in its willingness to embrace chaos, to let contestants like Jourdan Miller redefine beauty, and to accept that the next top model isn’t just a face—it’s a movement.

For now, the show endures as a mirror to the industry’s contradictions: a relic of the past clinging to the future. And that, perhaps, is its greatest strength.

Comprehensive FAQs

Q: How has what is America’s next top model changed since Tyra Banks left?

The show’s shift from Tyra Banks’ tenure (2003–2015) to the reboot under new judges reflects broader industry changes. Early seasons emphasized "classic" beauty and high fashion, while modern iterations focus on digital literacy, diversity, and personal branding. The introduction of a "diversity director" and challenges like social media growth mirror the industry’s move toward inclusivity and tech-savviness.

Q: Can contestants still "make it" after winning what is America’s next top model?

Yes, but the path has evolved. Winners like Nyle DiMarco and Jourdan Miller have leveraged their platforms for activism and advocacy, while others (e.g., McKey Sullivan) transitioned into acting. However, traditional modeling contracts are rarer; today’s winners often monetize through social media, brand deals, and niche industries like fitness or sustainability.

Q: How does the show’s casting process work in 2024?

Casting is now primarily digital, with applicants submitting photos and videos via the show’s website. The top candidates are invited to in-person auditions in major cities, where they’re evaluated on stage presence, portfolio quality, and social media following. The show’s diversity director ensures representation across body types, ethnicities, and abilities, though final selections still prioritize "marketability."

Q: What skills do contestants need to win in the current era of what is America’s next top model?

Beyond traditional modeling skills (e.g., runway walking, posing), contestants must demonstrate digital savvy—growing a following, creating content, and engaging with trends. Judges now evaluate "personal brand" potential, meaning authenticity and relatability are as critical as looks. Physical fitness and mental resilience are also key, as challenges often push contestants to their limits.

Q: Is what is America’s next top model still relevant compared to platforms like TikTok?

The show’s relevance lies in its structured approach to career development, which TikTok lacks. While platforms like TikTok can launch models overnight, ANTM provides education, industry connections, and a curated platform. However, the show must continue innovating—whether through virtual challenges, sustainability focuses, or deeper ties to activism—to stay ahead of self-made influencers.