George Washington Wasn't Our First President—Who Really Led America First?

Published

Table of Contents

The story of America’s first presidency is a tale of political ingenuity, constitutional gray areas, and a leadership vacuum that forced the nation to improvise. While George Washington’s election in 1789 is etched in textbooks as the birth of the executive branch, the reality is far more nuanced. The office of president didn’t materialize overnight—it emerged from a patchwork of temporary roles, congressional power struggles, and the desperate need for a unifying figure during the Revolutionary War. The man who officially holds the title of "first president" might surprise you, and the circumstances surrounding his tenure reveal how fragile the young nation’s governance truly was.

The confusion stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of the Articles of Confederation, the document that governed the U.S. from 1781 until 1789. Under its terms, there was no president in the modern sense—no executive branch, no veto power, and no commander-in-chief with broad authority. Instead, the Continental Congress rotated a President of the United States in Congress Assembled, a ceremonial and administrative role with no real executive control. Yet, this position became the de facto leadership of the nation during a critical decade. The man who first occupied it, John Hanson, is often overlooked, but his presidency set precedents that would later shape Washington’s tenure.

Even Washington’s own contemporaries questioned whether he was truly the first president. In 1789, when Congress created the office of president under the new Constitution, they didn’t retroactively declare Washington’s predecessor roles invalid. Some Founding Fathers, like Thomas Jefferson, privately acknowledged the existence of earlier "presidents" under the Articles, though they were never formally recognized in official records. The omission wasn’t accidental—it was a deliberate erasure, as the new federal government sought to distance itself from the perceived weaknesses of the Confederation era. Yet, the truth persists: George Washington wasn’t our first president, and the leaders who came before him played a pivotal, if underappreciated, role in holding the nation together.

###
george washington wasn't our first president

The Complete Overview of America’s First Presidential Era

The period between the Declaration of Independence and the ratification of the Constitution was one of constant experimentation in governance. With no established executive, the Continental Congress relied on a rotating presidency—a system designed to prevent tyranny but which left the nation vulnerable to disorganization. The President of the United States in Congress Assembled was elected annually by the Congress, serving as its presiding officer, foreign diplomat, and symbolic head of state. This role was not just ceremonial; it required navigating treaties, military logistics, and diplomatic crises with Britain and Spain. The man who first held this title, John Hanson of Maryland, was elected in November 1781, just as the Revolutionary War was drawing to a close.

Hanson’s presidency was marked by urgency. He oversaw the ratification of the Treaty of Paris (1783), which ended the war, and established the Department of Foreign Affairs (the precursor to the State Department). Yet, his legacy was overshadowed by the chaos of the Confederation era. Congress struggled with financial collapse, interstate trade disputes, and the threat of Shays’ Rebellion, which exposed the Articles’ fatal flaws. The lack of a strong executive meant that Hanson—and the eight men who followed him—had to govern through persuasion and consensus, a system that proved unsustainable. By the time Washington was elected in 1789, the nation was desperate for a leader who could command respect, both at home and abroad.

The transition from the Confederation presidency to the constitutional presidency was seamless in name only. The new Constitution’s Article II created a single, four-year-term presidency with real executive power, but it didn’t erase the prior roles. Some historians argue that the Founders intentionally downplayed the earlier presidencies to legitimize Washington’s authority. Others see it as a case of historical amnesia, where the drama of the Constitution’s creation overshadowed the messy, improvisational years that preceded it. What’s undeniable is that the office evolved incrementally, with each "president" under the Articles contributing to the blueprint for the role Washington would later define.

###

Historical Background and Evolution

The idea of a rotating presidency under the Articles of Confederation was born out of distrust—distrust of centralized power, distrust of monarchy, and distrust of any single leader accumulating too much authority. The Founders, having just broken free from British rule, were hyper-sensitive to the concentration of power. The Continental Congress, which functioned as both a legislative and executive body, elected its president annually, ensuring no one could become too entrenched. This system was a direct response to the lack of a clear executive in the Articles, which deliberately avoided creating a president in the modern sense.

The first eight men to serve as President of the United States in Congress Assembled—John Hanson, Elias Boudinot, Thomas Mifflin, Richard Henry Lee, Nathan Gorman, Arthur St. Clair, Cyrus Griffin, and finally, John Hancock—are often referred to as the "Presidents of the United States under the Articles of Confederation." Their terms were not just symbolic; they were critical. Hancock, for instance, presided over Congress in 1787, the year the Constitutional Convention met in Philadelphia. His leadership during this pivotal moment suggests that the Confederation presidency was more influential than commonly acknowledged. Yet, when the Constitution was ratified, the new government chose to ignore these predecessors, focusing instead on Washington as the inaugural president of the United States.

The erasure wasn’t just about political convenience—it was also about rebranding. The Confederation Congress was widely criticized for its ineffectiveness, and acknowledging its presidents would have undermined the legitimacy of the new federal government. The Founders needed a clean break, and Washington’s military leadership provided the perfect narrative. But the truth is that the office of president didn’t begin with Washington; it began with Hanson, a farmer and merchant who became the first man to hold the title. His presidency, though brief, established the precedent that the U.S. would have a single leader, even if the Articles never explicitly defined the role.

###

Core Mechanisms: How It Worked

Under the Articles of Confederation, the President of the United States in Congress Assembled had no independent authority. Unlike the constitutional presidency, this role was entirely dependent on the Congress. The president’s duties included:
  • Presiding over Congress, ensuring order and fairness in debates.
  • Signing official documents, including treaties and diplomatic correspondence.
  • Acting as a liaison with foreign governments, though all major decisions required congressional approval.
  • Overseeing the military, though the Continental Army’s commander (Washington) answered directly to Congress, not the president.
  • The lack of executive power meant that these presidents had to rely on persuasion and diplomacy. For example, when John Hanson signed the Treaty of Paris (1783), he did so with the full backing of Congress, but the treaty’s ratification still required unanimous state approval—a process that took years. The system was designed to prevent tyranny, but it also made governance painfully slow. By contrast, Washington’s presidency under the Constitution allowed for decisive action, such as the Judiciary Act of 1789 and the creation of the Cabinet, which gave the executive branch real teeth.

    The confusion over who was the "first president" stems from the fact that the Articles never used the term "president" in the way we understand it today. The title was borrowed from the Continental Congress’s earlier practice of electing a president pro tempore. When the Constitution was drafted, the Founders could have acknowledged these earlier leaders, but they chose not to. Instead, they framed Washington’s election in 1789 as the true beginning of the presidency, despite the fact that the office had already existed in embryonic form for eight years.

    ###

    Key Benefits and Crucial Impact

    The often-overlooked presidencies under the Articles of Confederation were not just historical footnotes—they were essential experiments in governance. These leaders, though lacking formal power, provided critical stability during a time of economic and political upheaval. Their existence proves that the idea of a single executive was not born with the Constitution, but rather evolved from the necessity of leadership in the face of chaos. Without these early presidents, the transition to a stronger federal government might have been far more turbulent.

    Moreover, the Confederation presidency set important precedents. The annual rotation of the role ensured that no single leader could become too powerful, a principle that influenced the constitutional debate over term limits. The fact that these presidents were chosen by Congress also foreshadowed the Electoral College system, which was designed to balance popular sovereignty with state interests. Even the title itself—President of the United States in Congress Assembled—reflected the Founders’ belief that executive authority should be subordinate to legislative will, a tension that would later define Washington’s presidency.

    > "The powers delegated by the proposed Constitution to the federal government are few and defined. Those which are to remain in the State governments are numerous and indefinite." — James Madison, Federalist No. 45

    This quote underscores the delicate balance the Founders sought to strike. The Confederation presidency, though weak, was a necessary step toward understanding what a federal executive could—and should—be. Without these early experiments, the constitutional presidency might have been even more contentious, as the nation grappled with the question of how much power a single leader should wield.

    ###

    Major Advantages

    The early presidencies under the Articles of Confederation, despite their limitations, offered several key advantages:

    -

  • Established the concept of a single national leader, even if the role was ceremonial. This laid the groundwork for the constitutional presidency.
  • Provided continuity during the Revolutionary War and its aftermath, ensuring that the nation had a symbolic head of state during critical negotiations.
  • Demonstrated the need for a stronger executive, as the weaknesses of the Articles became painfully clear during economic crises and foreign policy challenges.
  • Set precedents for diplomatic protocol, such as the signing of treaties and the handling of foreign relations, which Washington later formalized.
  • Prevented the concentration of power in one individual, as the annual rotation ensured no president could become a monarch, a fear that haunted the Founders.
  • While these presidencies lacked the authority of the constitutional office, they were not without influence. For instance, John Hancock’s presidency in 1787 coincided with the Constitutional Convention, suggesting that his role may have been more substantive than previously thought. The fact that these leaders were often prominent figures—like Hancock, a signer of the Declaration of Independence—also lent legitimacy to the young nation’s governance.

    ###
    george washington wasn't our first president - Ilustrasi 2

    Comparative Analysis

    |
    Aspect | Presidency Under the Articles of Confederation (1781–1789) | Constitutional Presidency (1789–Present) |
    |--------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------|---------------------------------------------|
    |
    Authority | Limited to presiding over Congress; no executive power. | Broad executive powers, including veto, command of military, and appointment authority. |
    |
    Term Length | Annual, rotated among members. | Four-year terms (later extended to eight under the 22nd Amendment). |
    |
    Election Process | Elected by Congress from its own members. | Elected by the Electoral College (later influenced by popular vote). |
    |
    Key Achievements | Ratification of Treaty of Paris (1783), establishment of Department of Foreign Affairs. | Creation of the Cabinet, Judiciary Act of 1789, establishment of federal institutions. |

    The table above highlights the stark contrast between the two eras. The Confederation presidency was a legislative tool, while the constitutional presidency became a separate, co-equal branch of government. Yet, the transition wasn’t as abrupt as it seems. Many of the early constitutional presidents, including Washington, drew on the experiences of their predecessors. For example, the idea of a Cabinet (though not yet formalized) was influenced by the informal advisory roles that Confederation presidents relied on.

    ###

    The debate over who was America’s first president is more than a historical curiosity—it reflects broader questions about how leadership evolves in times of crisis. As scholars continue to uncover archival evidence, it’s likely that the roles of the Confederation presidents will gain more recognition. Future research may even lead to official acknowledgment of their contributions, particularly as modern governance grapples with questions of executive authority in federal systems.

    Additionally, the story of these early leaders offers lessons for contemporary politics. The annual rotation of the presidency under the Articles was an attempt to prevent tyranny, but it also created instability. Today, debates over term limits and the concentration of power echo the same tensions that defined the Founding Era. Understanding how the first presidents under the Articles navigated these challenges could provide valuable insights into balancing democracy with effective leadership.

    ###
    george washington wasn't our first president - Ilustrasi 3

    Conclusion

    The myth that
    George Washington was the first president of the United States persists because it aligns with a narrative of orderly progress—one where the Constitution was a clean break from the past. But history is rarely so neat. The truth is that the presidency began in obscurity, with a series of leaders who held the title without the power, yet who kept the nation together during its most vulnerable years. Recognizing their contributions doesn’t diminish Washington’s legacy; it enriches it by placing his presidency in the context of the experiments that preceded it.

    As America continues to debate the role of the executive branch, the story of these early presidents serves as a reminder that governance is an ongoing evolution. The Founders didn’t get it right the first time—they improvised, adapted, and built on the mistakes of the past. In that sense, the real first president wasn’t just one man, but a collective effort to define what leadership in a republic should look like.

    ###

    Comprehensive FAQs

    Q: Who was the first president under the Articles of Confederation?

    A: The first President of the United States in Congress Assembled was John Hanson of Maryland, elected in November 1781. He served a one-year term, overseeing the final stages of the Revolutionary War and the ratification of the Treaty of Paris (1783). Despite his historical significance, Hanson is rarely mentioned in standard U.S. history curricula.

    Q: Why isn’t John Hanson considered the first U.S. president?

    A: The omission stems from a deliberate historical narrative shift when the Constitution was ratified in 1789. The Founders wanted to present Washington’s presidency as the true beginning of the executive branch, partly to distance the new government from the perceived failures of the Confederation era. Additionally, the Articles of Confederation never used the term "president" in the modern sense, leading to confusion over titles.

    Q: How many presidents served under the Articles of Confederation?

    A: Eight men held the title President of the United States in Congress Assembled between 1781 and 1789. They were:
    1. John Hanson (Maryland)
    2. Elias Boudinot (New Jersey)
    3. Thomas Mifflin (Pennsylvania)
    4. Richard Henry Lee (Virginia)
    5. Nathan Gorman (Pennsylvania)
    6. Arthur St. Clair (Pennsylvania)
    7. Cyrus Griffin (Virginia)
    8. John Hancock (Massachusetts)
    Each served one-year terms, with Hancock’s presidency coinciding with the Constitutional Convention in 1787.

    Q: Did any of these early presidents have real power?

    A: No. The President of the United States in Congress Assembled had no independent executive authority. Their role was largely ceremonial and administrative, focusing on presiding over Congress, signing official documents, and acting as a diplomatic liaison. Major decisions—such as declaring war or ratifying treaties—required full congressional approval. However, their symbolic leadership was crucial during the Revolutionary War and its aftermath.

    Q: How did the transition from the Confederation presidency to Washington’s presidency work?

    A: The transition was seamless in practice but deliberate in narrative. When the Constitution was ratified, the new government did not retroactively invalidate the earlier presidencies, but it also did not officially recognize them. Washington’s election in 1789 was framed as the first presidency under the Constitution, though some Founding Fathers, like Thomas Jefferson, privately acknowledged the prior roles. The new executive branch absorbed many of the informal functions performed by the Confederation presidents, such as diplomatic leadership and military oversight.

    Q: Are there any modern efforts to recognize these early presidents?

    A: Yes, though limited. Some historians and advocacy groups, such as the John Hanson Heritage Society, have pushed for greater recognition of Hanson and his successors. In 2016, Maryland’s state legislature officially recognized Hanson as the "first president of the United States," though this designation is not federally recognized. The debate continues among historians, with some arguing that the omission is a case of historical revisionism designed to elevate Washington’s legacy.

    Q: Could the U.S. have functioned without these early presidential roles?

    A: It’s unlikely. The President of the United States in Congress Assembled provided critical stability during the Revolutionary War and the chaotic post-war period. Without a symbolic leader, the Continental Congress might have struggled even more with internal divisions and foreign relations. The role, though weak, ensured that the nation had a unifying figurehead during a time when governance was still being defined. The Confederation presidency was, in many ways, a necessary stepping stone to the constitutional presidency.