The Forgotten VP: Who Was RFK’s Running Mate in 1968?
Table of Contents
- The Complete Overview of RFK’s 1968 VP Selection
- Historical Background and Evolution
- Core Mechanisms: How It Works
- Key Benefits and Crucial Impact
- Major Advantages
- Comparative Analysis
- Future Trends and Innovations
- Conclusion
- Comprehensive FAQs
- Q: Why did RFK choose John Lindsay over other potential running mates like Ted Kennedy?
- Q: How did John Lindsay’s selection affect the 1968 Democratic National Convention?
- Q: What would have happened if RFK had lived and won the election?
- Q: Did John Lindsay run for higher office after 1968?
- Q: How did RFK’s assassination change the VP selection process?
- Q: Are there any modern parallels to RFK’s running mate selection?
The 1968 presidential election was a turning point in American history—a year when hope collided with tragedy, and the Democratic Party fractured under the weight of its own divisions. At its center stood Robert F. Kennedy, the younger brother of a slain president, a senator with a fiery oratory style, and a man who had just won California’s primary in a landslide. His victory was a defiant middle finger to the political establishment, but it also raised an urgent question: who would stand beside him as his running mate? The answer would not only define his campaign but also leave an indelible mark on the Democratic Party’s future.
The choice of a vice-presidential candidate is never merely symbolic; it is a strategic gambit, a balancing act between ideology, geography, and political survival. For RFK, the stakes were higher than most. His campaign was a grassroots revolution, fueled by disillusioned Democrats who saw him as the only alternative to the war in Vietnam and the entrenched power of the Johnson administration. Yet, the party’s leadership, still reeling from Lyndon B. Johnson’s withdrawal and Hubert Humphrey’s shaky nomination, resisted RFK’s challenge. The question of who was RFK’s running mate was not just about policy—it was about legacy, unity, and whether the Democratic Party could heal its wounds before the November election.
By the time RFK entered the race in March 1968, the Democratic Party was in chaos. Anti-war protesters clashed with police in Chicago, Eugene McCarthy’s primary challenge had exposed LBJ’s vulnerabilities, and the party’s old guard feared a Kennedy-led insurgency would split the coalition. RFK’s decision to run was impulsive, born of frustration and a belief that he could unite the fractured left. But unity required more than rhetoric—it required a running mate who could appeal to the party’s moderates, its urban voters, and its disaffected liberals. The man he ultimately chose, John Lindsay, was a bold but risky selection, one that reflected both RFK’s vision and the desperate need to bridge divides in a nation on the brink.

The Complete Overview of RFK’s 1968 VP Selection
The selection of who was RFK’s running mate was one of the most consequential—and controversial—decisions of the 1968 campaign. Unlike traditional VP picks, which often prioritized experience or regional balance, RFK’s choice was driven by a need to signal change, inclusivity, and a break from the past. His selection of New York City Mayor John Lindsay was a statement: a young, progressive, and urban leader who embodied the anti-establishment spirit of RFK’s coalition. Yet, Lindsay’s selection also exposed the tensions within the Democratic Party, where many saw him as too liberal, too untested, and ultimately, too much of a wildcard for a general election.
The process itself was shrouded in secrecy and urgency. RFK had only weeks to decide after his California primary win on June 4, 1968—a date forever marked by his assassination in Los Angeles just minutes after declaring victory. Before that night, however, he had quietly narrowed his options. Names like Ted Kennedy (his younger brother), George McGovern (the anti-war senator), and even Nelson Rockefeller (the liberal Republican) were floated. But Lindsay emerged as the frontrunner, not because he was the safest choice, but because he represented the future RFK wanted to build—a multiracial, urban, and youth-driven movement. The decision was announced on June 5, 1968, just hours before RFK’s death, making it one of the most fleeting and tragic VP selections in history.
Historical Background and Evolution
The Democratic Party’s VP selection process in 1968 was unlike any other. Traditionally, presidential nominees deferred to the party’s elders, often choosing a seasoned politician to balance their ticket. But RFK’s campaign was different. It was a movement, not a machine, and his supporters demanded a running mate who reflected their values: anti-war, pro-civil rights, and unapologetically progressive. The party’s leadership, however, was still dominated by Johnson loyalists and Southern conservatives who viewed RFK’s candidacy as a threat to their power. This tension set the stage for a VP search that was as much about politics as it was about principle.
The assassination of Martin Luther King Jr. in April 1968 had already radicalized the Democratic base, pushing many to reject the party’s moderate wing. RFK’s entry into the race capitalized on this momentum, but it also forced him to confront the reality that his coalition was fragile. Black voters, who had overwhelmingly supported LBJ in 1964, were now divided between RFK and the more radical candidates like McCarthy. Lindsay’s selection was an attempt to bridge this gap—a white liberal who had supported civil rights and urban renewal, yet was not seen as a threat to black voters. However, his lack of national name recognition and his association with New York’s political scandals made him a polarizing figure among Democrats.
Core Mechanisms: How It Works
The mechanics of selecting a running mate in 1968 were far less formalized than today. There was no national convention process, no structured vetting, and certainly no modern polling or focus groups. Instead, RFK relied on a small circle of advisors—including his brother Ted, campaign manager Fred Dutton, and strategist Paul Markham—to weigh the options. The criteria were simple: the candidate had to be young (to energize the base), urban (to appeal to city voters), and progressive (to counter Humphrey’s moderate image). Lindsay fit all three, but his selection also carried risks. As a mayor, he lacked the gravitas of a senator or governor, and his past support for controversial policies (like rent control) alienated some conservatives.
What made Lindsay’s selection even more daring was the timing. RFK had only a matter of weeks to decide, and the assassination loomed over every conversation. The campaign’s inner circle knew that if RFK won the nomination, he would need a running mate who could immediately step into the spotlight—a task Lindsay, with his charisma and media savvy, was theoretically equipped to handle. Yet, the lack of time for vetting and the suddenness of RFK’s death meant that Lindsay’s role would never be tested. His name was announced, the ticket was formed, and then, in an instant, the campaign was over.
Key Benefits and Crucial Impact
The decision to pair RFK with John Lindsay was a gamble, one that reflected the desperation of a campaign that had no time for caution. On paper, Lindsay brought youth, urban appeal, and a progressive pedigree—qualities that resonated with RFK’s base. His selection was meant to signal that the Democratic Party was evolving, that it could embrace a new generation of leaders who were unburdened by the failures of the past. For black voters, Lindsay’s record on civil rights and his support for open housing were critical. For young voters, his image as a reformer was irresistible. And for moderates, his status as a mayor (rather than a senator) suggested a more pragmatic, less ideological approach.
Yet, the impact of this choice was ultimately overshadowed by history. RFK’s assassination on June 5, 1968, just hours after Lindsay’s selection, ensured that their ticket would never take flight. But the decision’s ripple effects were profound. It demonstrated the Democratic Party’s willingness to take risks in the face of crisis, and it set a precedent for future VP selections that prioritized symbolism over experience. Lindsay’s brief stint as a VP nominee also highlighted the growing influence of urban politicians—a trend that would later define the careers of figures like Michael Bloomberg and Cory Booker.
—Robert F. Kennedy, June 4, 1968 (final speech):
"The greatness of our nation rests on the broad shoulders of our people. Together, we can restore dignity, hope, and unity to this land. And if we do that, we will not only win this election—we will win a new beginning for America."
Major Advantages
- Youth and Energy: Lindsay, at 45, was one of the youngest potential VP candidates in history, appealing to the anti-establishment youth vote that RFK had energized.
- Urban Appeal: As New York City’s mayor, Lindsay brought credibility with urban voters, a demographic that had increasingly turned against the Democratic Party.
- Progressive Credentials: His support for civil rights, open housing, and urban renewal aligned perfectly with RFK’s platform, reinforcing the campaign’s progressive message.
- Media Savvy: Lindsay was a natural in front of cameras, a skill that would have been invaluable in a general election where TV debates were becoming decisive.
- Symbolic Unity: His selection was seen as a bridge between RFK’s liberal base and the party’s moderate wing, a rare attempt at reconciliation in 1968.

Comparative Analysis
| Aspect | RFK’s Selection (Lindsay) vs. Humphrey’s Selection (Muskie) |
|---|---|
| Demographic Appeal | Lindsay targeted urban, young, and progressive voters; Muskie focused on the Midwest and traditional Democrats. |
| Political Experience | Lindsay had executive experience (mayor) but lacked national prominence; Muskie was a seasoned senator with deep party ties. |
| Policy Alignment | Lindsay’s liberal record matched RFK’s anti-war stance; Muskie’s moderation clashed with Humphrey’s hawkish image. |
| Legacy Impact | Lindsay’s selection was a bold but untimely gamble; Muskie’s was a safe, conventional choice that failed to energize the base. |
Future Trends and Innovations
The RFK-Lindsay ticket, though short-lived, foreshadowed the future of Democratic VP selections. The party’s increasing reliance on urban, progressive candidates—seen later in figures like Kamala Harris and Stacey Abrams—can be traced back to 1968. Lindsay’s selection was an early recognition that the Democratic base was shifting away from rural and Southern moderates toward a coalition of city dwellers, minorities, and young voters. This trend would define the party’s strategy for decades, culminating in the 2020 election with Biden’s choice of Harris, a senator from California with a similarly progressive and urban appeal.
Yet, the Lindsay pick also serves as a cautionary tale. His lack of national experience and the suddenness of RFK’s death demonstrated the risks of selecting a running mate based on symbolism alone. Modern campaigns now balance this approach with rigorous vetting, ensuring that VP candidates can not only inspire but also govern. The RFK campaign’s failure to test Lindsay’s viability in a general election remains a lesson in the dangers of haste in political strategy.

Conclusion
The question of who was RFK’s running mate is more than a historical footnote—it is a window into the turbulent soul of 1968 America. John Lindsay’s selection was a bold, if ultimately tragic, attempt to redefine the Democratic Party’s future. It reflected RFK’s vision of a movement-based politics, one that prioritized ideals over institutional caution. Yet, it also exposed the fragility of that vision in the face of violence, division, and the relentless march of history. Lindsay’s brief moment in the spotlight was snuffed out by an assassin’s bullet, but his legacy endured as a symbol of the progressive spirit that RFK sought to embody.
Today, as the Democratic Party continues to grapple with its identity, the RFK-Lindsay ticket serves as a reminder of the power—and peril—of taking risks. The choice of a running mate is never just about policy; it is about legacy, about who we aspire to be as a nation. In 1968, RFK and Lindsay dared to imagine a different America. Their story is a testament to the enduring struggle between hope and reality in politics.
Comprehensive FAQs
Q: Why did RFK choose John Lindsay over other potential running mates like Ted Kennedy?
A: RFK considered Ted Kennedy but ultimately chose Lindsay to broaden his appeal beyond the Kennedy family’s base. Lindsay’s urban credentials and progressive record made him a stronger choice for uniting the party’s fractured liberal and moderate wings. Additionally, selecting Ted Kennedy might have alienated non-Kennedy Democrats, while Lindsay offered a fresh, non-establishment face.
Q: How did John Lindsay’s selection affect the 1968 Democratic National Convention?
A: Lindsay’s selection was announced just hours before RFK’s assassination, so it had no direct impact on the convention. However, his name was briefly floated as a compromise candidate to unify the party after RFK’s death, though Humphrey ultimately secured the nomination. Lindsay’s role in the convention was minimal, but his selection symbolized the anti-war, urban wing of the party that Humphrey struggled to represent.
Q: What would have happened if RFK had lived and won the election?
A: Had RFK survived and won in November 1968, Lindsay’s role as VP would have been pivotal in shaping his administration. As a reform-minded mayor, Lindsay likely would have influenced urban policy, civil rights, and anti-war initiatives. However, his lack of national experience might have limited his impact, and the ticket’s progressive lean could have faced resistance from moderates in Congress.
Q: Did John Lindsay run for higher office after 1968?
A: Yes. Despite the 1968 setback, Lindsay remained a prominent figure in New York politics. He served as mayor until 1973, ran for president in 1972 (finishing third in the New Hampshire primary), and later became a U.S. representative. His 1968 VP bid, though brief, solidified his reputation as a progressive leader in the Democratic Party.
Q: How did RFK’s assassination change the VP selection process?
A: RFK’s death exposed the vulnerabilities of hastily made VP selections. While the 1968 process was already informal, later campaigns (like Carter’s selection of Mondale in 1976) adopted more structured vetting to avoid similar risks. The tragedy also highlighted the need for a clearer succession plan, influencing how modern candidates prepare for unexpected crises.
Q: Are there any modern parallels to RFK’s running mate selection?
A: Yes. Biden’s 2020 selection of Kamala Harris mirrors RFK’s choice of Lindsay in several ways: both were progressive, urban, and aimed at energizing a younger, more diverse voter base. However, unlike Lindsay, Harris had national experience (as a senator and California AG), reducing the risk of a similar political miscalculation.
Leave a Comment
Comments are moderated before appearing. The data you submit is processed according to the Privacy Policy of Sentry.