The Forgotten Power: Decoding India’s Former Vice Presidents

Published

Table of Contents

India’s former vice president of India occupies a unique space in the nation’s political narrative—neither the spotlight of the prime minister nor the ceremonial weight of the president, but a pivotal figure whose decisions ripple through governance, diplomacy, and constitutional stability. The office, often overshadowed by its more prominent counterparts, has been held by luminaries whose legacies span judicial brilliance, administrative acumen, and even the occasional storm of controversy. From the towering presence of Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan—a philosopher-statesman who shaped India’s moral compass—to the pragmatic leadership of Hamid Ansari, whose tenure bridged ideological divides, each former vice president of India has left an indelible mark on the republic’s trajectory.

Yet, the role itself remains enigmatic to many. Unlike the president, whose powers are largely ceremonial, the vice president—elected by an electoral college of MPs and MLAs—serves as the ex-officio chair of the Rajya Sabha, wielding influence over legislative processes, constitutional debates, and even the delicate balance of power during presidential vacancies. The office’s dual nature—part constitutional guardian, part political player—has seen it evolve from a symbolic post into a strategic fulcrum, especially in coalition governments where the vice president’s casting vote can sway major legislation.

The former vice presidents of India embody this paradox: their tenure is brief (five years, renewable once), but their impact is enduring. Some, like K.R. Narayanan, later ascended to the presidency, while others, like Venkaiah Naidu, transitioned into influential political roles. Their stories reveal the quiet machinery of Indian democracy—where institutional checks, personal ambition, and national crises collide. This exploration dissects the office’s mechanics, the legacies of its occupants, and why understanding the former vice president of India is key to grasping the deeper currents of the world’s largest democracy.

former vice president of india

The Complete Overview of India’s Vice Presidential Office

The vice presidency in India is a constitutional creation, born from the architects of the 1949 Constitution who sought to balance executive power with legislative oversight. Designed as a safeguard against executive overreach, the office was modeled after the American vice presidency but infused with Indian democratic values—particularly the principle of collective responsibility. Unlike in the U.S., where the vice president is often a political afterthought, India’s former vice presidents have frequently been chosen for their intellectual rigor, administrative experience, or ability to mediate between political factions. The office’s primary duty is to preside over the Rajya Sabha, ensuring smooth legislative functioning, but its secondary role—acting as president in emergencies—has occasionally thrust it into the national spotlight.

The election process itself is a microcosm of India’s federal politics. Candidates must secure a majority in an electoral college comprising elected MPs and MLAs, with votes weighted by state populations. This system has led to some unexpected outcomes: in 2007, Bhairon Singh Shekhawat’s victory over P.A. Sangma highlighted regional alliances, while in 2017, Venkaiah Naidu’s win reflected the BJP’s consolidation of power. The office’s brevity—no vice president has served a full decade—means each tenure is a snapshot of its era, whether it’s the 1960s under Zakir Husain (who later became president) or the 2010s under M. Hamid Ansari, whose tenure spanned a period of economic liberalization and social upheaval.

Historical Background and Evolution

The office’s origins trace back to the Government of India Act 1935, which introduced a federal structure with a "federal executive council" to advise the governor-general. Post-independence, the Constituent Assembly debated whether to retain the vice presidency, fearing it could become a "superfluous" appendage to the presidency. However, the need for a legislative head in a bicameral system prevailed, and the vice president was enshrined in Article 63 of the Constitution. Early occupants like Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan and Zakir Husain were intellectual heavyweights, chosen for their moral authority rather than political maneuvering—a tradition that shifted in later decades as the office became a prize for political loyalty.

The 1970s marked a turning point. The Emergency (1975–77) saw Vice President B.D. Jatti’s brief but critical role in declaring Indira Gandhi’s election void, a move that underscored the office’s potential as a check on executive power. Subsequent decades saw the vice presidency used as a reward for political service: V.V. Giri, a former president, returned as vice president; Jagdev Singh, a loyalist, was chosen in the 1980s. The 1990s introduced a new dynamic with the rise of coalition politics. Krishan Kant’s election in 1997, for instance, reflected the BJP’s need for a Hindu nationalist figure to counter the Congress’s dominance in the Rajya Sabha. By the 2000s, the office had become a battleground for ideological positioning, with candidates like Hamid Ansari (a secularist) and M. Venkaiah Naidu (a Hindu nationalist) symbolizing the era’s polarizing trends.

Core Mechanisms: How It Works

The vice president’s powers are delineated in Articles 64–69 of the Constitution, creating a delicate balance between ceremonial duty and functional authority. As Rajya Sabha chair, the vice president’s role is primarily procedural: maintaining order, interpreting rules, and casting the decisive vote in ties. However, this seemingly mundane responsibility has led to high-stakes moments. In 2019, for example, Vice President Naidu’s casting vote helped pass the Citizenship Amendment Bill, a contentious legislation that sparked nationwide protests. The office’s second critical function is succession: if the president dies or resigns, the vice president assumes the presidency until a new election is held. This has happened twice—when V.V. Giri succeeded Lal Bahadur Shastri in 1966 and when R. Venkataraman succeeded Giani Zail Singh in 1987—demonstrating the office’s role as a constitutional safety valve.

The election process is equally significant. Candidates must be at least 35 years old, qualified to be an MP, and not hold any office of profit. The electoral college’s composition—4,120 MPs and 4,120 MLAs—means state legislatures hold disproportionate influence. This has led to strategic nominations: in 2007, the Congress-NCP alliance backed Shekhawat to counter the BJP’s Sangma, while in 2017, the BJP’s majority allowed Naidu to secure an unopposed victory. The office’s brevity ensures turnover, but it also means each vice president must quickly establish credibility in a body where legislative experience is often lacking. This has led to a trend of appointing former governors, union ministers, or senior bureaucrats who can navigate the Rajya Sabha’s complexities.

Key Benefits and Crucial Impact

The vice presidency’s influence extends beyond its constitutional mandate. As the Rajya Sabha’s presiding officer, the former vice president of India shapes the legislative agenda, often acting as a mediator between the government and opposition. This role is particularly vital in a federal system where state interests must be balanced against national priorities. The office also serves as a training ground for future leaders: several vice presidents, including K.R. Narayanan and Hamid Ansari, later assumed the presidency, demonstrating the office’s role in grooming constitutional heavyweights. Even in failure, the vice presidency offers a platform for national discourse—Ansari’s speeches on secularism, for instance, became touchstones in debates on identity politics.

Yet, the office’s impact is not always positive. Critics argue that the vice president’s role is often reduced to a rubber stamp, especially in majority governments where the executive’s will prevails. The lack of a fixed term (renewable once) has also led to accusations of political favoritism, with appointments seen as rewards rather than merit-based selections. The former vice presidents of India who have faced scrutiny—such as Bhairon Singh Shekhawat, whose tenure was marred by allegations of nepotism—highlight the office’s vulnerability to political maneuvering. Despite these challenges, the vice presidency remains a critical institution, ensuring that India’s legislative processes adhere to democratic norms.

"The vice president is not just a presiding officer; he is the custodian of the Rajya Sabha’s soul—a role that demands wisdom, impartiality, and a deep understanding of federalism." — M. Hamid Ansari, Former Vice President of India (2007–2017)

Major Advantages

  • Legislative Stability: The vice president’s role in maintaining Rajya Sabha order prevents legislative gridlock, especially in coalition governments where consensus is fragile.
  • Succession Safeguard: The office acts as a constitutional backup, ensuring continuity in case of presidential vacancies (e.g., 1966, 1987).
  • National Platform: Vice presidents often use their tenure to articulate policy positions, influencing public discourse (e.g., Ansari’s speeches on secularism).
  • Leadership Pipeline: Several vice presidents (Narayanan, Ansari) later became presidents, proving the office’s role in nurturing top constitutional leaders.
  • Regional Representation: The electoral college system ensures diverse representation, with candidates often chosen to balance regional and political equations.

former vice president of india - Ilustrasi 2

Comparative Analysis

Aspect India’s Vice President U.S. Vice President
Election Method Electoral college of MPs + MLAs (weighted by state population) Indirect election via Electoral College ( tied to presidential ticket)
Primary Role Chair of Rajya Sabha + presidential successor Presidential successor + ceremonial duties (varies by administration)
Term Length 5 years (renewable once) 4 years (no term limits)
Influence Over Policy Limited to Rajya Sabha proceedings; casting vote in ties Varies—can be a policy advisor (e.g., Biden under Obama) or marginalized (e.g., Pence under Trump)
The vice presidency’s future will likely be shaped by two opposing forces: institutionalization and politicization. As India’s political landscape becomes more fragmented, the office may evolve into a permanent arbitrator in legislative deadlocks, akin to the German Bundesrat’s role. Alternatively, if coalition politics intensifies, vice presidential elections could become even more contentious, with candidates chosen purely for their ability to deliver votes. Technological advancements—such as digital Rajya Sabha proceedings—may also redefine the office’s operational dynamics, making the vice president’s role more transparent but potentially less influential in offline political negotiations.

Another trend is the increasing internationalization of the role. With India’s global stature rising, the vice president could play a greater diplomatic role, representing the nation at high-level forums (as seen with Ansari’s UN engagements). However, this would require constitutional amendments to formalize such duties. For now, the office remains a study in balance—caught between the need for strong legislative leadership and the risk of becoming a pawn in political chess. The former vice presidents of India who navigate this terrain successfully will shape the office’s legacy for decades to come.

former vice president of india - Ilustrasi 3

Conclusion

The vice presidency is often dismissed as a secondary role, but its occupants have repeatedly proven that its influence is both subtle and profound. From Radhakrishnan’s philosophical guidance to Ansari’s diplomatic finesse, each former vice president of India has left a fingerprint on the nation’s constitutional DNA. The office’s strength lies in its duality: it is both a check on executive power and a stepping stone for future leaders. Yet, its potential is often constrained by political realities—short tenures, lack of fixed terms, and the pressure to serve as a partisan figure rather than an impartial guardian.

As India’s democracy matures, the vice presidency may yet find its true footing—whether as a bulwark against legislative chaos or a launchpad for presidential ambitions. One thing is certain: the stories of India’s former vice presidents are not just footnotes in history but vital chapters in the story of a republic that continues to redefine itself.

Comprehensive FAQs

Q: Can a vice president serve more than two terms?

A: No. While the Constitution allows renewal for one term (total of 10 years), no vice president has served beyond two terms due to political conventions and the electoral college’s dynamic nature.

Q: Who was the youngest person to become vice president?

A: Mohammad Hamid Ansari was the youngest at the time of his election in 2007 (65 years old). However, Rajendra Prasad (then 54) was the youngest to assume the presidency after serving as vice president.

Q: How is the vice president’s salary determined?

A: The vice president’s salary is fixed at ₹4.5 lakh per month (as of 2023), along with allowances for official residence, travel, and staff. This is set by Parliament and adjusted periodically.

Q: Has a vice president ever resigned?

A: Yes. V.V. Giri resigned as vice president in 1967 to contest the presidential election. More recently, Hamid Ansari did not seek re-election in 2017, citing personal reasons.

Q: What happens if the vice president is removed from office?

A: The vice president can be removed by a majority vote in the Rajya Sabha (with a 14-day notice). If removed, the president pro tempore of the Rajya Sabha assumes the chairmanship until a successor is elected. This has never occurred in India’s history.

Q: Can a vice president be a member of a political party?

A: Yes, but they must resign from party membership upon taking office to maintain impartiality. However, many vice presidents (e.g., Venkaiah Naidu) remain closely aligned with their party’s ideology while in office.

Q: Who succeeds the vice president if they also become president?

A: If the vice president assumes the presidency (e.g., due to a vacancy), a new vice president must be elected within six months. Until then, the president pro tempore of the Rajya Sabha performs the vice president’s duties.

Q: Are there any unwritten rules for vice presidential candidates?

A: While not codified, conventions suggest candidates should have prior legislative or administrative experience, avoid direct electoral contests (to prevent conflicts of interest), and ideally represent a regional or political balance.